top of page

Setauket Harbor Pond Park

Constrained Historical Design

Proposal

 Joseph A. Betz, Architect
Professor & Former Chair

Department of Architecture & Construction Management

Farmingdale State College

State University of New York

----

This work was presented to the Three Village Civic Association.

This is as an educational tool used at Farmingdale State College, SUNY

----

© Copyright 2024, All rights reserved.

Constrained Historical Design: a design that is highly constrained by the context and seeks to preserve many historical aspects and authentic natural features of the site.  

Plan 4.jpg

Overall Conceptual Area Map

Plan 1.jpg

Downtown Image Map Overlay

3D 2.jpeg

Ensemble of Principle buildings on Main Street  

Ensemble of Principle buildings on Main Street  

3D 7d.jpg

Old Garage Building, Main Street  

Pavilion Animation.gif

Proposed Pavilion, Main Street  

Rationale:

1. Preserves the historic facade, streetscape and form.

2. Provides public restroom facilities in the front (solid).

3. Provides possible concession and storage facilities.

4. Hides possible playground and parking behind.

5. Provides quiet sound barrier of street noise behind restrooms and creates an inside vs. outside feeling.  In addition, the building acts as a visual barrier to State Route 25A creating a peaceful sanctuary in the park.

6. The majority of the building becomes a void space that allows the park to be more visible. 

7. Saves construction renovation costs (can be smaller).

8. Saves on heating and cooling a large indoor space (life cycle).

9. Allows year-round "Passive" use (not under lock and key) with less staff and organized effort.

10. Can be scaled smaller for additional cost savings (2+ options).

11. Finally, who goes to a park to sit inside conditioned space?

​​​​Budget Analysis:

The Existing structure is a 4140 SF wood frame building. To renovate the entire building for a municipal occupancy of Public Assembly, including mechanical /AC, sprinkler, electrical, plumbing, life safety, windows, interior finishes, flooring, and energy code updates, etc. is approx. $400/SF.

  • To renovate the entire building (no Pavilion) with all interior space: 4140SF at $400/SF is: $1,656,000.

  • The larger Pavilion Proposal, interior renovation of 1240 SF at $400/SF ($496,000) plus the open-air canopy of 2740 SF at $90/SF ($246,600) is: $742,600 (44% less).

  • The smaller Pavilion Proposal interior renovation of 1240 SF at $400/SF ($496,000) plus the open-air canopy of 1520 SF at $90/SF ($136,800) is: $632,800 (38% less).

  • Additional reductions are possible reducing the cost while keeping the facade to define the original streetscape and provide public restrooms.

  • These estimates do not include sitework.

Plan 3.jpg

Conceptual Parking Layout for 98 Cars

circulation 2.jpg

Downtown Conceptual Circulation Plan

Bridge span.jpg

Overall Conceptual Circulation Plan

3D 9a.jpg

Parking near Se-Port Deli, Main Street  

Se-Port Deli 2.jpg

Removal of Parking near Se-Port Deli, Main Street  

Se-Port Deli.jpg
bottom of page